Article
In today’s ever-evolving digital landscape, cybersecurity has become a critical concern for employee benefit plan (“EBP”) committees. By effectively managing risks, they can prevent potential security breaches, protect plan participant data and assets, and ensure the continuity of their operations.
This article will explore the distinctions between three essential risk management approaches in cybersecurity: Vendor Risk Management, Third-Party Risk Management, and Enterprise Risk Management..
Understanding the importance of risk management in cybersecurity
Before we explore the differences between the various risk management approaches, it’s crucial to understand why risk management is vital in the EBP committee room. Cyber threats have become more sophisticated and pervasive with the rapid advancements in service providers’ technology.
Federal regulators have imposed a major burden on EBP committees by implementing multiple laws that place fiduciaries on the front line of conformance.
Implementing a comprehensive risk management framework enables fiduciaries to proactively identify vulnerabilities, establish controls, and respond effectively to potential threats.
Differentiating between vendor risk management, third-party risk management, and enterprise risk management
While all risk management approaches aim to protect an EBP plan’s digital assets, each focuses on different risk aspects.
- Vendor Risk Management (“VRM”) primarily concerns the dangers of utilizing third-party vendors for goods or services. It involves assessing the security measures within these vendor relationships and ensuring they align with an organization’s cybersecurity standards.
- On the other hand, Third-Party Risk Management (“TPRM”) encompasses a broader scope. It involves evaluating the risks associated with all external parties interacting with an organization, including vendors, suppliers, contractors, and partners. TPRM aims to assess the potential vulnerabilities these external parties may introduce into an organization’s systems and processes.
- Lastly, Enterprise Risk Management (“ERM”) takes a holistic approach to risk management. It involves identifying and managing risks across an entire organization, including all departments and functions. ERM considers risks from all sources, including cybersecurity risks, and integrates risk management practices into an organization’s overall strategic planning and decision-making processes.
The role of each risk management approach in cybersecurity
While each risk management approach focuses on different aspects of risk, they collectively contribute to a comprehensive cybersecurity strategy.
- VRM ensures that it adequately addresses the risks associated with vendor relationships. The prudent selection and monitoring of vendors is the VRM principle enforced on employers by the U.S. Department of Labor.
- TPRM expands this scope to encompass all external parties in a third-party vendors’ supply chain, the so-called subservice vendors, mitigating the risks these entities introduce.
- ERM integrates risk management practices across an organization, ensuring they consider cybersecurity risks in the broader context of overall risk management.
By adopting all three approaches, organizations can establish a robust cybersecurity risk management framework that addresses risks at various levels and ensures a holistic approach to security.
Best practices for implementing VRM
Implementing effective VRM requires a workflow approach built on best practices.
Firstly, EBP committees should establish a comprehensive vendor risk assessment process, including evaluating potential vendors’ security controls and practices. The assessment should rely on predefined criteria that align with regulatory cybersecurity standards.
Secondly, committees should develop clear policies and procedures that outline vendor expectations and requirements. These policies should address data protection, incident response, and compliance with relevant regulations.
Lastly, organizations should regularly monitor and assess the performance of their vendors to ensure ongoing compliance with the established risk management protocols.
Best practices for implementing TPRM
To effectively implement TPRM, EBP committees should adopt a proactive and comprehensive approach.
Firstly, conducting thorough due diligence when onboarding new external parties is crucial. This due diligence should involve evaluating the potential risks associated with the engagement, including cybersecurity risks.
Secondly, committees should establish clear contractual agreements that outline the security requirements and expectations for third parties. These agreements should include provisions for regular security assessments, incident reporting, and the enforcement of security controls.
Lastly, organizations should implement a robust monitoring and auditing process to ensure that third parties continuously meet the established security standards. They should conduct regular risk assessments that identify weaknesses or vulnerabilities and address them promptly.
Best practices for implementing ERM
Implementing ERM requires a strategic and coordinated approach throughout the organization.
Firstly, organizations should establish a risk management framework defining roles, responsibilities, and processes. This framework should ensure that risk management practices integrate into all levels of the organization.
Secondly, organizations should define risk appetite and tolerance levels, aligning them with business objectives. That helps in prioritizing risks and allocating resources effectively. Additionally, regular risk assessments should identify emerging risks and assess the effectiveness of existing risk mitigation strategies. Organizations should also develop and implement a comprehensive risk mitigation plan with appropriate controls, policies, and procedures.
Lastly, monitoring and reporting risks are essential to ensure that risk management efforts remain effective and adaptive to changing circumstances.
The importance of collaboration between risk management approaches
While each risk management approach has its distinct focus, collaboration between these approaches is crucial for effective cybersecurity risk management. Vendor, third-party, and enterprise risk management should work harmoniously to create a synchronized methodology. By sharing information and insights, organizations can gain a holistic view of their risk landscape, identify potential interdependencies, and address risks more effectively. Collaboration enables organizations to align risk management efforts with their overall business objectives, facilitating better decision-making and resource allocation.
Tools and technologies for effective risk management in cybersecurity
In the digital age, numerous tools and technologies can enhance the effectiveness of risk management in cybersecurity. Risk assessment tools like those offered by Roland|Criss enable organizations to assess and quantify risks more accurately. These tools provide a systematic approach to identifying vulnerabilities, evaluating their impact, and prioritizing risk mitigation efforts.
Cyber-ProtectRC from Roland|Criss delivers real-time monitoring and analysis of security events, enhancing a plan sponsor’s incident response capabilities. By leveraging these tools and technologies, EBP committees can improve risk management practices and strengthen cybersecurity defenses.
Conclusion: The need for a comprehensive approach to cybersecurity risk management
A comprehensive cybersecurity risk management strategy is crucial in today’s digital landscape. For EBP committees moving toward principled performance based on governance, risk management, and compliance capability, VRM, TPRM, and ERM can strengthen their defenses against cyber threats.
Take the first step towards enhancing your cybersecurity posture by assessing your current risk management practices and identifying areas for improvement. Proactive risk management is vital to safeguarding digital assets and business continuity.
Contact us…
Maintain a sharp edge on your employee benefit plan management skills with membership in this executive-level community.
